Hexcrawl maps for players: What's best for gameplay, player's maps with or without hexes?

I’m putting together a hexcrawl setting for DnD 5e called Langden Mire. I want to give players a map so that they can orientate themselves and decide where to head to. The PCs will start in the fishing village of Cobham, where they will be tasked with finding a Green Hag who lives in the Mire and convincing her to brew up a cure for a sick child. Of course, the player’s map is incomplete and there are lots of other interesting locations for the PCs to discover.

One question I’ve been puzzling over is whether to make the hexcrawl mechanics explicit by including the hexes on the player’s map. The player’s map on the left has only a scale to indicate distance. The map on the right has 6-mile hexes overlaid as well. I can see pros and cons of both approaches. For example, The Alexandrian makes a cogent argument that the DM should hide the hexcrawl structure from the players

https://thealexandrian.net/wordpress/17308/roleplaying-games/hexcrawl

so that players interact more with the game world rather than the hexcrawl abstraction. At the same time I wondered if some players would like to see the hex map so that they can make informed decisions about the game.

I thought I’d ask on reddit as to whether people preferred a player’s map with or without hexes. My expectation was that most people would not care too much, so I found the resulting discussion rather surprising. Roughly half of commenters had a strong preference for hexes and the other half had a strong preference for not having hexes. There was a smaller proportion of commenters who were happy with either.

There were strong arguments against hexes on the map since it reduced the player’s immersion by making the mechanics of the hexcrawl too apparent. There were also strong arguments for hexes on the player’s map, so that the players could make clearly informed decisions about what to do next. Personally, I’m agnostic as to whether to include hexes or not on a player’s map. I think that when I get around to running the hexcrawl I’ll simply ask my players what they prefer.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Is random weather in role-playing games too random? Using simple Markov chains to make RPG weather more realistic (Markov Chain Weather Part 1)

Image
Weather is important in role-playing games. This is especially true in wilderness and seafaring exploration adventures, where poor weather can affect navigation, travel speed, and visibility. In this post, I'll describe a method to generate random weather using a simple Markov chain (see the end of the post for the tables). Nearly all RPGs provide some way to randomly generate weather and include its impacts. One of the problems with random weather tables is that they tend to be “too random”. Rolling once a day on a random weather table can result in the weather jumping unrealistically between different types (Storm! Cold Weather! Hot Weather! Storm! etc.). Real weather isn’t completely random all the time. For example, mid-latitude weather tends to flip between regimes of unsettled stormy weather and regimes of settled weather. When the weather is unsettled things do indeed feel random as the passage of storms and fronts bring rain, snow, and strong winds. But when the weather is ...
Read more

Barrow of the Two Brothers: One Page Dungeon

Image
My entry into the 2021 One Page Dungeon Contest can be found here .  The Barrow of the Two Brothers is a short adventure for a Level 1-2 party. Two long-dead brothers, Ethelred and Olaf, are buried in the barrow. In life, they fought and murdered each other over their dying Mother’s crown and as a final punishment they were interred together. The spirits of the two brothers haunt the barrow, waiting for someone to finally allow them to rest.
Read more

Creating localized RPG weather using a simple Markov Chain - an example of a foggy swamp (Markov Chain Weather Part 3)

Image
The weather can vary a lot from one location to another. For example, fog can form in a swampy valley even when the surrounding hills are clear. Similarly,  precipitation in a mountain range is more likely to fall as snow and winds will be stronger. I’ve previously posted about using a simple Markov Chain to generate mid-latitude RPG weather that has realistic time variations. This post describes an extended Markov Chain method to produce weather that also varies from location to location. 
Read more